Re-decided holding: Cox is not contributorily liable because the Copyright Act does not authorize secondary liability for mere failure to terminate service, and any such liability must be created by Congress under Article I, Section 8, Clause 8, with clear statutory language.

Verified Values for America participants only: national results count accounts with a verified email; state and district results count only those who also attested a home ZIP code. Participants choose to take part, so this is not a random sample or a poll of all residents; ± is the 95% sampling margin and does not correct for self-selection. A breakdown publishes at 30 verified votes. Methodology.