Constitution Index · H.Con.Res. 89 · 2026-04-23

Directing the President, pursuant to section 5(c) of the War Powers Resolution, to remove United States Armed Forces from hostilities with Iran.

Latest official status (2026-09-24): Failed of passage in Senate by Yea-Nay Vote. 49 - 50. Record Vote Number: 244.

Official source ↗

Constitutional grade

A

Constitutional

HCONRES 89 is constitutional. It enforces Congress's Article I war-declare power by ending unauthorized hostilities with Iran while preserving self-defense, infringes no Bill of Rights protection, takes no property without due process, and properly exercises federal authority over war rather than consolidating new federal power.

Article I Article I, Section 8, Clause 11 Article I, Section 8, Clause 14 Amendment I Amendment II Amendment IV Amendment VIII Amendment X Amendment V

SI-generated grade · passed automated checks (real Constitution citation, language rules) · not individually reviewed by a person · methodology · Report an error: hello@valuesforamerica.com

The five checks

Enumerated powers · passes

Ordering removal from unauthorized hostilities is squarely within congressional authority. Article I, Section 8, Clause 11 grants Congress power to declare war, and Article I, Section 8, Clause 14 grants power over the government and regulation of the Armed Forces. Section 5(c) of the War Powers Resolution implements that authority. A concurrent resolution directing an end to undeclared hostilities enforces, rather than exceeds, enumerated powers.

Bill of Rights · passes

This resolution restricts government war-making, it does not restrict private rights. It implicates no First Amendment speech, religion, press or assembly interest, no Second Amendment arms interest, no Fourth Amendment search, and no Fifth through Eighth Amendment trial or punishment interest. By restoring congressional control over hostilities, it protects the Ninth and Tenth Amendments' reservation of unlisted rights and powers to the people. No provision exists.

Individual liberty · passes

The resolution imposes no restriction on any person's body, property, speech, labor, or belief. It restricts only the federal executive's conduct of hostilities without authorization. Because no private freedom is burdened, the government bears no additional justification burden here, and sovereignty of the individual is left fully intact.

Decentralization · passes

National defense and war with a foreign state cannot be handled by an individual, county, or single state, so the first three questions are answered no. The action does not consolidate power upward; it does the opposite by moving the decision to use force from the executive back to Congress as the Tenth Amendment and separation of powers require. De-centralization within the federal level is constitutionally correct for war powers.

Due process and takings · passes

No person is deprived of life, liberty, or property, and no property is taken. The resolution orders no punishment, creates no tribunal, and presumes no guilt. It therefore satisfies Fifth Amendment procedural and substantive due process and raises no Takings Clause issue requiring just compensation.

Provenance

Grade ID
162
Rubric version
vfa-constitutional-grade/1.0
Graded
2026-10-08 10:34 UTC
Engine
primary SI engine
Source fetched
2026-10-07 08:04 UTC
Source SHA-256
e34bc0c1b536f180eb2ccabfe0ee29b3f64e67a29567447bb046faa650150891
Checks
si-editorial-standard/1.0: real Constitution citation, language rules

Version history · never overwritten

GradeGradedRubric Source hashStatus
A · #162 2026-10-08 vfa-constitutional-grade/1.0 e34bc0c1b536 current

Cite this

Values for America. “Constitutional grade: H.Con.Res. 89, Directing the President, pursuant to section 5(c) of the War Powers Resolution, to remove United States Armed Forces from hostilities with Iran..” VFA Constitution Index, grade 162 (rubric vfa-constitutional-grade/1.0), graded October 8, 2026. https://www.valuesforamerica.com/constitution-index/grades/162. Accessed 2026-10-19.

Permalink: https://www.valuesforamerica.com/constitution-index/grades/162

Data: this grade as JSON · full export. Attribution required.

← The Constitution Index